The proton coupled amino acid transporter PAT1 expressed in intestine, brain, and other organs accepts L- and D-proline, glycine, and L-alanine but also pharmaceutically active amino acid derivatives such as 3-amino-1-propanesulfonic acid, L-azetidine-2-carboxylic acid, and cis-4-hydroxy-D-proline as substrates. We systematically analyzed the structural requirements for PAT1 substrates by testing 87 amino acids, proline homologs, indoles, and derivatives. Affinity data and effects on membrane potential were determined using Caco-2 cells. For aliphatic amino acids, a blocked carboxyl group, the distance between amino and carboxyl group, and the position of the hydroxyl group are affinity limiting factors. Methylation of the amino group enhances substrate affinity. Hetero atoms in the proline template are well tolerated. Aromatic alpha-amino acids display low affinity. PAT1 interacts strongly with heterocyclic aromatic acids containing an indole scaffold. The structural requirements of PAT1 substrates elucidated in this study will be useful for the development of prodrugs.