Inguinal sentinel node dissection versus standard inguinal node dissection in patients with vulvar cancer: A comparison of the size of metastasis detected in inguinal lymph nodes
Introduction
The American Cancer Society estimates that there will be 3870 new cases of vulvar cancer with 870 deaths from this disease for the year 2005 [1]. Traditionally, patients with vulvar malignancies underwent a radical vulvectomy with en bloc inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy. However, the complication rates associated with the classic approach were high, with up to 69% of patients experiencing chronic lymph edema and 85% wound breakdown [2]. More recently, in an attempt to reduce the morbidity associated with radical vulvar surgery, patients have been treated with radical wide local excisions or hemivulvectomies and superficial groin node dissections. A GOG study evaluating limited surgery with wide local excision and superficial groin node dissection reported a decrease in the rate of chronic lymph edema to 19% and wound infection and or separation to 29% [3]. The presence of inguinal lymph node metastasis is correlated with survival. The 5-year survival rate in women with negative inguinal lymph nodes for metastasis is 96% compared to 80% for patients with two positive nodes and 12% for those with three or more positive nodes [4]. Although all patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma undergo complete inguinal lymph node dissection, only 27% will have nodal metastases and therefore 80% of women will have had a groin node dissection without any benefit and the exposure to the risk of the surgery [4].
Sentinel lymph node technology has provided the means for identifying the sentinel lymph node draining a tumor bed and provides for its removal through minimally invasive surgery. Inguinal sentinel lymph node dissection in vulvar cancer patients has been shown to be feasible and highly sensitive for the detection of metastatic disease to the inguinal nodal basin [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]. These studies have shown a nearly 100% identification rate of a SLN when lymphatic mapping with a radioactive tracer (Tc-99m sulfur colloid) is used in combination with blue dye. The negative predictive value of a negative sentinel lymph node in these studies has been shown to be 100% [5]. The utilization of a sentinel node dissection allows for an in-depth pathologic examination of the one or two sentinel lymph nodes through the use of pathologic ultra-staging allowing for the detection of micrometastasis [10].
We hypothesize that the average size of metastasis detected in non-palpable inguinal nodes is smaller when detected through the use of SLN dissection and ultra-staging versus complete inguinal node dissection.
Section snippets
Materials and methods
This was an IRB approved retrospective study. The Program in Women's Oncology tumor registry database at Women and Infants' Hospital was searched from 1990 to 2004 and identified 336 inguinal groin dissections in patients with a vulvar malignancy. Sentinel inguinal lymph node (SLN) dissections were performed in 52 groins and complete lymph node dissections (CND) alone in 284 groins. Patients with clinically suspicious lymph nodes (lymph nodes greater than 1 cm or palpable nodes) were excluded
Results
Three hundred and thirty six inguinal node dissections were performed in patients with primary vulvar malignancies. Thirty-four patients were identified that underwent SLN dissections through a prior SLN study and an ongoing SLN study. Eighteen of these patients had bilateral groin dissections totaling 52 groins. Of the 336 groin dissections, 284 underwent CND alone and 52 underwent SLN dissections. Only 66 groins were found to have nodal metastasis, 57 with CND, and 9 with SLN dissection. In
Discussion
The surgical treatment of vulvar cancer has evolved over the last few decades from radical en bloc resection of the vulva and groin nodes to radical wide local excision with separate inguinal node dissection. As well, the surgical approach to the evaluation of groin nodes has evolved from deep inguinal groin dissection to superficial inguinal groin dissections [11]. In a further attempt to decrease the morbidity associated with inguinal node dissection, sentinel lymph node technology has been
References (11)
- et al.
Sentinel node identification and the ability to detect metastatic tumor to inguinal lymph nodes in vulvar malignancies
Gynecol. Oncol.
(2003) - et al.
Intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel node identification with blue dye in patients with vulvar cancer
Gynecol. Oncol.
(2001) - et al.
A pilot study utilizing intraoperative lymphoscintigraphy for identification of the sentinel lymph nodes in vulvar cancer
Gynecol. Oncol.
(1997) - et al.
An alternate approach to early cancer of the vulva
Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.
(1979) - et al.
Cancer statistics, 2005
CA Cancer J. Clin.
(2005)