TABLE 1

Comparison of Optical Imaging Modalities

ParameterFluorescenceBioluminescenceOptoacousticCL
PrincipleAbsorption of light excites status of dye and its relaxation emits lightOxidation of substrate by enzyme emits lightLight is absorbed and causes molecular vibrations that emit sound wavesCharged particles travel quickly through medium and emit light
AdvantageEasy to perform; large variety of dyesNo incident radiation needed; no backgroundSafeSafe and informative
DisadvantageNeeds excitation sourceIs not yet clinicalNeeds complex image reconstructionNeeds radioactive preinjection
Translatable?YesNot currentlyYesYes
Ease to implementMediumMediumMediumDifficult
Ease to useEasyMediumMediumMedium
Ease to detectEasyEasyMediumMedium
Detectable rangeVisible spectrum and NIR470–750 nm400–800 nm (RSOM), 680–980 nm (MSOT)Ultraviolet-to-visible spectrum
Preclinical applicationsIn vitro and in vivo molecular imagingIn vitro and in vivo molecular imagingIn vivo tumor and vasculature imagingIn vivo tumor imaging
Potential clinical applicationsScreening, diagnostic, intraoperativeStem cell or chimeric antigen receptor T-cell trackingMuscular dystrophy, vasculature, cancer imagingPositive lymph nodes and cancer detection
CostLowLowMediumHigh