TABLE 2

MSE Between Noisy and CNN-Filtered Cylindric Phantom Images with Noiseless Image as Reference

Total counts in millions
Image type10.90.80.70.60.50.40.30.20.1
MeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSDMeanSD
Original61.571.6468.011.4676.851.9287.171.74102.041.70121.822.52153.813.03204.724.98305.888.41610.5614.50
B-CNN11.100.5111.650.4912.450.6613.170.4914.420.6116.010.9718.110.9420.861.3825.611.5039.682.47
M-CNN6.570.346.950.397.540.438.160.489.060.5210.390.8312.430.9315.110.8320.711.2536.362.17
C-CNN5.840.356.220.446.810.467.530.478.360.519.620.7811.550.8614.250.7120.401.1240.082.78
Gaus359.421.5865.641.4174.181.8684.141.6898.501.64117.582.44148.462.92197.584.79295.228.14589.3013.96
Gaus527.190.8429.790.7733.340.9137.370.7643.420.9251.091.3863.821.5083.862.16123.753.76245.176.14
Gaus722.120.7023.120.7324.660.7226.270.6828.920.8531.841.1537.261.3145.311.6461.482.10112.093.99
Gaus931.190.7831.670.8132.670.7833.630.8335.320.9336.901.1540.301.3845.021.6654.581.7485.063.35
Gaus1148.870.9149.060.9249.810.9050.461.0351.681.0652.571.2054.931.5158.011.7964.291.7184.413.07
Gaus1369.291.0169.331.0169.950.9870.451.1671.411.1971.941.2573.751.6275.981.9280.601.7895.223.01
Med917.580.8619.080.9120.920.8623.240.9926.200.9829.971.4036.501.5546.132.2665.222.52123.375.07
Med2532.221.5533.151.5034.051.4835.231.4836.432.1938.381.6641.372.1446.942.8756.362.9888.634.29
Med4972.972.4373.621.9273.812.4575.031.9474.952.7676.092.8578.273.1582.503.5889.854.23116.645.18
Med81117.122.68117.552.44117.192.55117.622.42118.112.71118.922.68120.673.12124.073.51131.243.51159.075.13
  • B-CNN = bone CNN; M-CNN = mix CNN; C-CNN = cylinder CNN; Gaus = Gaussian filter; Med = median filter.

  • Values represent mean MSE of 40 noise realizations.