TABLE 1

Advantages and Limitations of Ablative Techniques Most Frequently Used in Liver

ParameterRFAMWACryoablation
Mechanisms of actionOscillating electric current (ions)Dielectric hysteresis (water)Joule Thompson (Argon gas)
Range of temperature obtained±100°C>100°C−170°C to 0°C
Performance of imaging monitoringLowMid (gas formation)High (ice ball)
MarginsLargeSharpSharp
CollagenInjuredInjuredRespected
Size of ablation<3 cm<3–5 cm<5 cm
Mean length of procedure15 min10 min30 min
CostLowMidHigh