TABLE 1

Summary of Criteria of Previously Proposed Prognostic Scoring Systems

Prognostic scorePrognostic variable
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center clinical risk score (Fong et al. (6))Node-positive primary tumor
Disease-free interval from primary tumor
Number of liver metastases
Preoperative CEA level
Diameter of largest tumor
Pittsburgh system (Iwatsuki et al. (7))Bilobar tumors
Disease-free interval from primary tumor
Number of liver metastases
Diameter of largest tumor
Extrahepatic metastatic disease
Positive surgical margins
Nordlinger score (Nordlinger et al. (8))Age
Diameter of largest tumor
Extension of primary cancer to serosa
Node-positive primary tumor
Disease-free interval from primary tumor
Surgical margin
Basingstoke index (Rees et al. (9))Node-positive primary tumor
Differentiation of primary tumor
Number of liver metastases
Preoperative carcinoembryonic antigen level
Diameter of largest tumor
Extrahepatic metastatic disease
Hepatic resection margins