TABLE 3

Characteristics and Results of Published Studies II (n = 12)

StudyMean age PET/CG*Sex m/wInterventionControl groupStudy designPrimary outcomeResults*
Beanlands et al. 2007 (PARR-2) (23,24)63/62PET: 184/34PETStandard careMBSDComposite cardiovascular outcomeNegative
CG: 179/33
Fisher et al. 2009 (25)63/64PET: 53/45PET/CTCWUMBSDNumber of futile thoracotomiesPositive
CG: 49/42
Herder et al. 2006 (26)63/65PET: 158/74PETCWUMBSDNumber of tests and procedures to finalize staging and to define operabilityNegative
CG: 155/78
Maziak et al. 2009 (14)67/66PET: 83/87PET/CTCWUMBSDCorrect upstaging of cancer, avoiding stage-inappropriate surgeryPositive and negative
CG: 83/84
Picardi et al. 2007 (20)30/31Radiation: 45/35Additional radiotherapy PET-positives onlyAdditional radiotherapy for all patientsEnrichmentEvent-free survivalNegative
CG: 44/36
Plewnia et al. 2007 (27)58PET: 5/1PET/rTMSSham stimulationMBSDReduction of symptoms (tinnitus questionnaire)Positive
CG: 5/1
Ruers et al. 2009 (13)62.6/62.9PET: 48/27PET/CTCTMBSDNumber of futile laparotomies§Positive
CG: 56/19
Siebelink et al. 2001 (28)62 ± 2/63 ± 1PET: 40/9PETSPECTMBSDCardiac event-free survivalNegative
CG: 49/5
Sobhani et al. 2008 (29)58.1/62.0No informationPETConventional follow-upMBSDRecurrence after 9 and 15 mo; OSNegative
van Tinteren et al. 2002 (PLUS) (30,31),66/65PET: 69/23PET + CWUCWUMBSDNumber of futile thoracotomiesPositive
CG: 75/21
Tsai et al. 2010 (32)53.4 ± 11.9No informationPET-guided radiotherapyStandard radiotherapyMBSDDisease-free-survival and OS at 2 y after treatmentNegative
Viney et al. 2004 (33)66/68PET:66/25PETCWUMBSDNumber of thoracotomiesNegative
CG: 68/24
  • * Results according to authors’ conclusions.

  • CCO = Composite cardiovascular outcome at 1 y: cardiac death, myocardial infarction, transplantation, or rehospitalization for unstable angina or heart failure.

  • Median age.

  • § Primary outcome in study protocol: disease-free survival (9 mo) and economic evaluation (9 mo); primary outcome in publication: number of futile laparotomies.

  • MBSD = marker-based strategy design; CG = control group; CWU = conventional work-up; rMTS = repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; OS = overall survival.