TABLE 1

Characteristics of 10 Studies Included in Metaanalysis

Author, year, and referencenStage III/IV patients (%)DesignMaskingIndication of node dissectionPrevalenceTechniqueQUADAS score
Rose/1999 (40)32Included (81)ProspectiveNRCT negative25%PET10
Narayan/2001 (37)26Included (12)RetrospectiveYesCT negative*19%PET7
Reinhardt/2001 (38)12Not includedProspectiveYesPalpable node25%PET8
Lin/2003 (35)50Included (NR)ProspectiveNoCT negative28%PET9
Roh/2005 (39)28Included (8)ProspectiveYesAll patients7%PET9
Wright/2005 (42)45Not includedRetrospectiveNRSurgeon's decision9%PET and PET/CT8
Choi/2006 (33)27Included (11)ProspectiveYesAll patients11%PET/CT11
Boughanim/2008 (32)38Not includedProspectiveYesPET/CT negative8%PET/CT9
Vergote/2008 (41)85Included (NR)ProspectiveNRPET/CT negative11%PET and PET/CT12
Yildirim/2008 (43)16Included (19)ProspectiveYesCT negative25%PET/CT8
  • * Five of 26 patients had positive node on CT and received paraaortic nodal sampling.

  • NR = not reported.