TABLE 1

Summary of Main Properties of 8 PVE Correction Approaches*

PropertyRCGTMDeconvolutionPartition basedMultiresolutionFittingAnatomic maximum a posterioriKinetic modeling
Assumes tumor is spheric?NoNoNoNoNoYesNoNo
Assumes known tumor volume?YesYesNoYesNoYesYesNo
Assumes uniform tumor uptake?YesYesNot necessarilyYesNoYesNoNo
Assumption(s) regarding tissues surrounding tumorLocally uniform, known uptakePiecewise constant, unknown uptakeNoPiecewise constant, known uptakeGray levels correlated with those of anatomic dataLocally uniform, unknown uptakePartially knownNo
Needs anatomic data?Not necessarilyYes, registeredNoYes, registeredYes, registeredNoYesNot necessarily
Mode of actionAfter reconstructionAfter reconstructionAfter reconstructionAfter reconstructionAfter reconstructionAfter reconstructionDuring reconstructionAfter reconstruction, time series required
Type of resultsTumor uptake valueTumor average uptake valueTumor average uptake valueImage of tumor compartmentPVE-corrected imageTumor average uptake valuePVE-corrected imageKinetic parameters compensated for PVE
Reference(s) for PET tumor imaging7,17,18,22,23,50,51,53,5430373847,50
  • * Desirable properties are shown in bold type.