TABLE 4

Costs Accrued to Conventional (C) and Proposed (P) Algorithms

AlgorithmItemCost of item in base-case analysisMedicare rate or other cost basis
C, PH&P
 Initial comprehensive$149.47Medicare
C Follow-up (used to reassess for dementia in previously nondemented patient)$62.33Medicare
C, P Focused follow-up (used after treatment of abnormality found on H&P or laboratory tests)$38.36Medicare
C, PMRIMedicare
 Without contrast$608.12
 With and without contrast$1,294.17
C Neuropsychologic testing$84.33Medicare
C, PLaboratory testsMedicare
 CBC$4.76
 ESR$3.73
 T4$8.95
 TSH$23.21
 Basic metabolic panel$11.70
 Hepatic panel$11.29
 Folate (RBC, serum)$44.25
 Vitamin B12 level$20.83
 Syphilis serology$11.40
P Brain PET$1,661Medicare × private insurance ratio, brain to whole body
C, PExtra care needed for AD patient who progresses past early stage while going untreated because of false-negative diagnosis$30,000$40,000/y of care (51) × 0.75-y (minimum) average delay of progression with therapy (16,19,26,2831)
C, P1-y supply of cholinesterase inhibitor unnecessarily prescribed to Non-AD patient because of false-positive diagnosis$1,500Median cost for donepezil and rivastigmine (most common inhibitors in current use) based on survey of local pharmacies
  • H&P = history and physical examination; CBC = complete blood count; ESR = erythrocyte sedimentation rate; T4 = thyroxine (l-3,5,3′,5′-tetraiodothyronine); TSH = thyroid-stimulating hormone; RBC = red blood cell; Ref. = reference; Non-AD = no AD identified on neuropathologic examination.

  • Costs were based on Medicare outpatient reimbursement rates whenever possible. Costs include professional and technical components, where applicable, as listed in the 2001 Medicare Fee Schedule booklet.