Abstract
A wide range of radiolabeled test meals have been used for gastric emptying scintigraphy. The purpose of this study was to test whether 99mTc-sulfur colloid−labeled liquid egg white is as stable as 2 fresh whole eggs labeled with 99mTc-sulfur colloid and whether the cooking method is important. Methods: Whole eggs and liquid egg white were mixed with 99mTc-sulfur colloid and cooked by either microwaving or frying on a griddle. The cooked eggs were tested for breakdown after 2 and 4 h of incubation in gastric fluid or HCl. Results: Labeled liquid egg white, prepared by either method of cooking, exhibited less breakdown in gastric fluid than whole eggs. Whole eggs cooked in the microwave exhibited significantly more breakdown than liquid egg white. Conclusion: 99mTc-Sulfur colloid binds better to egg whites compared with whole eggs. These results emphasize the need to evaluate the stability of new radiolabeled test meal preparations, including the method of cooking.
Gastric emptying scintigraphy to measure the emptying of a radiolabeled meal has become the gold standard for assessing gastric motility. Historically, many facilities performing this test have standardized their own test meals. Although published guidelines for performing gastric emptying scintigraphy include examples of acceptable radiolabeled solid meals, no discussion or recommendation of cooking methods is included (1). Recently, however, there has been an attempt to develop a standard meal that could enable comparison of gastric emptying data obtained at various facilities (2). This meal, which uses a commercially available liquid egg white has been adopted recently as the recommended standard meal in a consensus guideline on gastric emptying scintigraphy by the Society of Nuclear Medicine and the American Neurogastroenterology and Motility Society (3).
Our facility had consistently used a meal that included 2 whole fresh eggs, beaten and mixed with 99mTc-sulfur colloid (99mTc-SC) and then cooked on a griddle. We considered replacing this labeled egg mixture with Tougas et al.'s international standard low-fat recommendation of 120 mL of the commercially available egg substitute, mixed with 99mTc-SC and cooked in a microwave oven (4).
The purpose of this study was to test whether the commercially available egg substitute labeled with 99mTc-SC and cooked in the microwave oven is as stable as 2 fresh whole eggs labeled with 99mTc-SC and cooked on a griddle.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Egg and Label Composition
Whole Egg Meal.
Two fresh large eggs were transferred from their shells to a cup and then beaten for 1 min with a plastic spoon until the yolks and whites were blended. 99mTc-SC (4.6 MBq, 125 μCi) was mixed with the eggs. This mixture was cooked either by griddle or by microwave.
Commercially Available Egg Substitute Meal.
The egg substitute (EggBeaters; ConAgra Brands, Inc.) is composed of pasteurized egg whites colored with β-carotene and does not contain fat or yolks. One portion (120 mL) of the egg substitute, equivalent to 2 large whole eggs, was mixed in a cup with 4.6 MBq of 99mTc-SC by stirring with a plastic spoon. This mixture was cooked either by griddle or by microwave.
Cooking Method
For griddle cooking, a nonstick electric griddle was sprayed with nonstick cooking spray and heated to medium heat. The egg/99mTc-SC mixture was poured onto the pan and cooked to a firm consistency, turning the egg to ensure complete cooking.
For microwave cooking, the egg/99mTc-SC mixture was mixed in a microwave-safe disposable cup (10-oz capacity), which was then microwaved at high power for 2 min, with stirring after 1 min (2).
Stability Test Method
Each labeled egg preparation was transferred to a plate and allowed to cool to room temperature. Portions of cooked egg weighing about 0.5 g each were placed in glass vials. Each portion was chopped to approximately 3- to 5-mm pieces with a metal spatula to simulate chewing. To each portion was added 1.25 mL of human gastric fluid (pH 1.5) from human subjects undergoing elective endoscopy or 1.25 mL of 0.032 M HCl (pH 1.5). Each procedure was performed in triplicate. The vials (24 with each solution) were capped and placed in a water bath at 37°C with orbital shaking at 200 rpm for up to 4 h.
For each vial, a filter was prepared from a 3-mL syringe barrel packed with a plug of surgical gauze (double thickness of 1-in. square gauze). Before use, the filter was wetted with 0.5 mL of 1% bovine serum albumin in isotonic saline; this was followed by a rinse of 1 mL of isotonic saline. In a single separate experiment, it was found that <5% of 99mTc-SC bound to the gauze after albumin pretreatment.
At 2 and 4 h, egg and digesting solution were transferred to the prepared filter to separate solids from liquids. The vial was rinsed once with 1 mL of isotonic saline and this rinse was poured through the filter. The filtrate, rinse, and gauze with egg solids were counted separately for 99mTc content in a well counter.
After counting, the extent of cloudiness from small particulates was assessed in filtrates (gastric fluid incubations only). This was done by measuring the light transmittance at 600 nm in a spectrophotometer.
Data Analysis
The values for triplicate samples in a group were compared with the values for another group by unpaired t test.
RESULTS
The appearance of the cooked egg preparations differed from each other (Fig. 1). After cooking, the egg substitute prepared by either microwaving or frying was homogeneous and rubbery. The fresh whole eggs cooked by frying had areas of inhomogeneity (narrow streaks of white). In contrast, the fresh whole eggs cooked by microwaving had very pronounced separate areas of white and yellow, with the white areas appearing to be one third to one half the volume of the cooked product. For the stability evaluation, care was taken to obtain a representative sample of both yellow and white areas of cooked egg.
Photograph of labeled eggs showing differences in homogeneity. (A) Egg substitute cooked in microwave. (B) Egg substitute cooked on griddle. (C) Whole eggs cooked in microwave. (D) Whole eggs cooked on griddle.
The results of filtering the egg digests are given in Table 1. In gastric fluid, the egg substitute prepared by either griddle or microwave was quite stable, with >95% of 99mTc remaining with the egg solids on the filter. Whole eggs, however, exhibited breakdown. After 2 h of incubation, whole eggs cooked on a griddle had significantly more decomposition than the egg substitute cooked on a griddle (P < 0.05). After 4 h of incubation, the difference did not reach significance (P = 0.14). Microwaved whole eggs exhibited even more breakdown at these times (P < 0.05 at 2 h and P < 0.00005 at 4 h compared with microwaved egg substitute at the same times). After 4 h of incubation, microwaved whole egg had broken down significantly more than griddle-cooked whole egg (P < 0.05). There was large variance among the samples of whole egg in gastric fluid, perhaps because of the heterogeneity of the cooked whole egg and the inherent friability of egg yolk. None of the preparations broke down appreciably in dilute HCl.
Percentage of 99mTc Remaining with Solid Egg
In gastric fluid, whole eggs tended to disintegrate into a milky suspension. This was more pronounced with microwaved whole eggs than with griddle-cooked whole eggs. In contrast, the egg substitute (cooked by either method) remained relatively intact in chunks, and the solution did not become cloudy. This qualitative observation is substantiated by the light transmittance measurements (Table 2), which indicate that the fresh eggs disintegrated into a fine suspension much more than the egg substitute.
Cloudiness of Filtrates After Incubation in Gastric Fluid Measured as % Light Transmission (% T) at 600 nm
DISCUSSION
Unlike most nuclear medicine procedures in which unit doses of prepared radiopharmaceuticals can be ordered from an outside provider, test meals for gastric emptying scintigraphy must be prepared in the nuclear medicine department. In a busy department, there is a need to make the preparation of such meals as rapid and convenient as possible. This must be balanced with validated meals, which give reliable binding and, therefore, accurate tracing of the solid component of the meal. In addition, the meal must be sufficiently palatable to be consumed entirely by a patient with gastroparesis. Many hospitals have adopted 99mTc-SC–labeled eggs (served with toasted bread) as an acceptable test meal for their studies.
One concern with eggs as the main protein component of the meal is that cooked eggs are easily broken down to small particles that may empty as liquid. Many hospitals use radiolabeled egg meals, however, because of availability, convenience, and patient acceptance. In prior direct comparisons of gastric emptying, a meal of labeled whole eggs (fried) served with toast exhibited emptying curves that were very similar to labeled chicken liver chunks in beef stew (5). A recent study showed that labeled egg substitute (cooked in a microwave) served with bread and jam had emptying curves that were similar to a labeled liver meal except at later time points (2).
The data from this study suggest that the egg substitute, when cooked either in a microwave oven or fried, has a firmer consistency that resists the tendency to disintegrate into small fragments when compared with fresh whole eggs. The egg substitute is largely egg white without fat or yolks. On the other hand, the whole eggs (white plus yolk) had a tendency to disintegrate when mixed together. This was likely related to the presence of the yolk, as the disintegration was more pronounced with the microwaved whole eggs in this study, which were very heterogeneous with large areas of yellow yolk separated from the egg white. 99mTc-SC is believed to bind to egg white protein as it becomes denatured during cooking. Adequate cooking appears to be necessary to achieve a stable label. There is no evidence that egg yolk, which is primarily fat, binds 99mTc-SC. Other brands of fat-free colored egg whites should be similarly tested for label stability.
When whole eggs were cooked by frying, they appeared to remain more homogeneous than whole eggs that were cooked by microwaving. This difference may be related to the nonuniform heating in the microwaved eggs, which allowed the albumin to separate from the yolks during the cooking process. When the eggs are fried on a griddle or in a skillet, the layer of liquid egg is relatively thin and is in contact with a higher temperature surface, which denatures the egg more quickly. It is conceivable that the microwaved whole eggs would separate less during cooking if they had been more vigorously beaten before cooking, but this was not tested to keep the procedure simple.
The stability data found in this study are in agreement with previously published data for 99mTc-SC−labeled whole eggs that were fried (5,6) and egg whites that were fried (7) or microwaved (4).
CONCLUSION
The following conclusions resulted from this study. (a) 99mTc-SC binds better to egg whites compared with whole eggs. (b) The stability of a radiolabeled solid test meal for gastric emptying studies must be established both for its constituents and for the method of preparation. (c) HCl is not an adequate substitute for gastric fluid for testing radiolabel binding to solid food.
Footnotes
-
COPYRIGHT © 2007 by the Society of Nuclear Medicine, Inc.
References
- Received for publication June 26, 2007.
- Accepted for publication August 18, 2007.
Jump to section
Related Articles
Cited By...
- Efficiency of Radiolabeling Eggs Before and After Microwave Cooking for Gastric Emptying Scintigraphy Studies
- Compliance with Gastric-Emptying Scintigraphy Guidelines: An Analysis of the Intersocietal Accreditation Commission Database
- Gastrointestinal Motility, Part 1: Esophageal Transit and Gastric Emptying
- Clinical Intervention for Quality Improvement of Gastric-Emptying Studies
- Reply: Egg Labeling for Gastric-Emptying Studies
- Egg Labeling for Gastric-Emptying Studies