Abstract
Pertechnetate (as 99mTcO4−), 123I−, and 131I− have a long and successful history of use in the diagnosis and therapy of thyroid cancer, with uptake into thyroid tissue mediated by the sodium-iodide symporter (NIS). NIS has also emerged as a potential target for radiotherapy of nonthyroid malignancies that express the endogenous or transfected symporter. Perrhenates (as 188ReO4− and 186ReO4−) are promising therapeutic substrates of NIS, although less is known about their behavior in vivo. In this study, we endeavored to characterize the biologic behavior of perrhenate, especially in relation to iodide and pertechnetate, to better explore its possible therapeutic role. Methods: We describe the simultaneous biodistribution and uptake in vivo of iodide, pertechnetate, and perrhenate in groups of healthy CD1 mice, either with or without coadministration of perchlorate (ClO4−), a potent NIS inhibitor. Animals administered single radiopharmaceuticals were imaged as a means of illustrating these findings. Kinetic properties of perrhenate were compared with those of iodide in a stably transfected NIS-bearing Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cell line. Results: Biodistributions of iodide, pertechnetate, and perrhenate in live mice were remarkably similar. Activity in salivary gland and stomach was severalfold greater than in blood, remained elevated over the initial 2 h, and subsequently washed out. A similar pattern characterized pertechnetate and perrhenate uptake by the thyroid, in which the 2-h concentration was slightly more elevated than at the 20-min time point. However, uptake subsequently decreased by 19 h. In contrast, iodide continued to increase through the 19-h time point, presumably as a result of organification. The addition of perchlorate sharply decreased uptake of all 3 radiopharmaceuticals by the stomach, salivary glands, and thyroid and resulted in their rapid clearance, paralleling blood-pool clearance. In tissues that do not express NIS (liver, muscle, spleen), uptake of all 3 radiopharmaceuticals was low and rapidly decreased over time, paralleling blood-pool clearance. Similar findings were seen in kidney, where only minimal amounts of NIS are expressed in tubular cells. In stably transfected MDCK cells, steady-state accumulation of iodide was approximately 4-fold higher than that of perrhenate at 30 min. No active transport was demonstrated in nontransfected MDCK cell lines or after perchlorate administration. Uptake values measured at different concentrations of substrate demonstrated saturation kinetics. Apparent maximal velocity values for perrhenate and iodide were 25.6 ± 1.4 and 106 ± 3.2 pmol/μg, respectively, and corresponding affinity constant values were 4.06 ± 0.87 and 24.6 ± 1.81 μmol/L. Conclusion: Perrhenate is avidly taken up by NIS in a manner similar to iodide and pertechnetate in vivo, with the exception of organification of iodide by the thyroid. By more fully appreciating the behavior of perrhenate, especially in relation to iodide and pertechnetate, we can better realize its potential role in the diagnosis and therapy of NIS-bearing tissues.
- dosimetry
- oncology
- radiobiology
- radionuclide therapy
- perrhenate
- pertechnetate
- radiotherapy
- sodium-iodide symporter
Iodide, in the form of 123I-NaI and 131I-NaI, has been used extensively in the imaging and treatment of hyperthyroidism and thyroid carcinoma. Uptake of iodide into thyroid tissue is mediated by the sodium-iodide symporter (NIS). Since cloning of the rat (1) and the human (2) forms of the molecule in 1996, NIS has been the subject of numerous studies concerning structure and function relationships and regulation (3–8). NIS-mediated active transport of iodide is driven by the Na+ electrochemical gradient generated by Na+/K+-adenosine triphosphatase, with 2 Na+ ions translocated into the cells per each iodide ion (9). NIS also mediates iodide uptake into other tissues known to concentrate iodide, such as stomach, salivary gland, and lactating breast (4). NIS expression has also been demonstrated in more than 80% of human mammary cancers, raising the possibility of administering 131I-NaI for therapy of breast malignancy (10–12). Furthermore, considerable interest has been expressed regarding radioiodide therapy after targeted transfection of NIS-containing vectors into non–NIS-bearing malignant tissues (13–16).
Although its main physiologic role is transport of iodide, NIS has been shown to transport other structurally similar anions. For example, pertechnetate (TcO4−) shares physicochemical attributes with iodide and exhibits similar biodistribution on radionuclide scanning, with the exception of organification within the thyroid, which occurs only with iodide. 99mTcO4− has therefore achieved an important clinical role as a surrogate for iodide in radionuclide imaging of NIS-dependent functions, including transport of substrate into the thyroid gland (historically known as “trapping”) and secretory function of the salivary glands and gastric mucosa (17–19). More recently, another structurally similar anion, perrhenate (ReO4−), has been proposed as a therapeutic radiopharmaceutical for treatment of NIS-bearing tumors (20). Rhenium, like technetium, is a member of the group VIIA elements of the periodic table. The radioactive moiety 188ReO4− is easily eluted from a 188W/188Re generator system. 188Re has a half-life of 17 h and emits high-energy β− particles (Eav = 0.795 MeV) and an imageable 155-keV γ-photon. Alternatively, perrhenate may be produced incorporating the reactor product 186Re. This radionuclide has a half-life of 91 h and emits medium-range β− particles (Eav = 0.362 MeV) and an imageable 137-keV γ-photon.
The biodistribution and properties of iodide and pertechnetate have been relatively well characterized, whereas less is known about perrhenate (20–23). As a close analog of pertechnetate, perrhenate would be expected to exhibit similar physical properties and binding behavior (24). Nonetheless, significant differences in chemical properties, such as reduction potential, may quantitatively alter the behavior of perrhenate in vivo (24). Fewer similarities are expected between perrhenate and iodide.
We have endeavored to characterize the biologic behavior of perrhenate using 2 techniques. We describe the simultaneous biodistribution of iodide, pertechnetate, and perrhenate in healthy CD1 mice to compare and contrast biodistribution and uptake in vivo. Additional mice administered single radiopharmaceuticals were imaged to illustrate these findings. These biodistribution studies were, to some degree, qualitative, in that the amount of substrate could not be readily controlled in a living animal in contrast to cell culture assays, in which the amounts of substrate can be rigorously controlled. We therefore also permanently transfected the Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cell line with NIS to characterize the kinetic properties of perrhenate uptake and compare them with those of iodide (7). By more fully understanding the behavior of perrhenate, especially in relation to iodide and pertechnetate, we begin to explore its possible role in diagnosis and therapy of NIS-bearing tissues, an area of emerging clinical interest (25).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In Vivo Biodistribution
99mTcO4− (630 KBq), 188ReO4− (630 KBq), and 125I− (63 KBq) in 0.1 mL of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) were coinjected in the tail vein in mice, with or without the addition of 2 mg of perchlorate (ClO4−), a powerful NIS blocker. Fifteen animals were in each group. 99mTcO4− was obtained commercially from a freshly eluted 99Mo/99mTc generator (Syncor International). 188ReO4− was locally eluted from a 188W/188Re generator (Oak Ridge National Laboratory). 125I− was obtained commercially (NEN). Within each group, 5 mice were killed at each of 20 min, 2 h, and 19 h. Eight tissues of interest (liver, muscle, spleen, kidney, blood, salivary gland, thyroid, and stomach) were removed and weighed on an analytic balance. 99mTc and 188Re were counted immediately using asymmetric windows and a dual-isotope–correcting program (Compugamma 1282; LKB Wallac); 125I was counted 8 d thereafter, after 99mTc and 188Re decay. Uptake was expressed as percentage of injected dose per gram of tissue (%ID/g) by comparison to a reference standard of injectate. For each radiopharmaceutical, a localization ratio was also generated by expressing the ratio of %ID/g in each tissue to that in blood.
To further illustrate the distribution of radionuclide visually, single anesthetized animals were injected with 18 MBq of 123I−, 99mTcO4−, or 188ReO4− and imaged supine on a dedicated research γ-camera (Picker Dynacamera 4C; Picker International) and computer system (Nuclear MAC; Scientific Imaging, Inc.) using a pinhole collimator positioned 13 cm above the animals. Images with 20% windows centered on each photopeak were dynamically acquired for 20 min after injection and thereafter at 24 min, 60 min, and 24 h. Standard-sized regions of interest (ROIs) were drawn around the thyroid, mediastinum, and stomach to derive time–activity curves that were normalized according to the total count rate of the initial images. Counts in each ROI were expressed in percentage of injected dose per ROI (%ID/ROI).
Generation of MDCK Cells Permanently Transfected with NIS
MDCK cells were transfected with the pcDNA 3.1(−) plasmid containing the human NIS cDNA, by means of the Fugene 6 transfection reagent (Roche), according to the manufacturer’s instructions. After selection in media containing 1 mg/mL Geneticine (G418 sulfate; GIBCO-BRL), NIS-expressing clones were isolated and expanded. The clone with the highest iodide uptake was used for these experiments.
Transport in Cultured Cells
Uptake of perrhenate and iodide using stably hNIS-transfected MDCK cells was characterized both as a function of time and of substrate concentration, according to previously described methods (1,7,26). Transport assays were determined in triplicate. For uptake experiments, cells grown in 12-well plates were washed twice with 1 mL of HEPES-buffered Hanks’ balanced salt solution (buffered HBSS) and incubated with buffered HBSS containing 20 μmol/L perrhenate or NaI supplemented with carrier-free 188ReO4− or Na125I, to give specific activities of 3.7 GBq/mmol. Additional control experiments were performed in the presence of the NIS inhibitor perchlorate (40 μmol/L) or using nontransfected MDCK cells. Incubations proceeded at 37°C for given reaction times in a humidified atmosphere and were terminated by aspirating the radioactive medium and washing twice with 1 mL ice-cold HBSS. Cells were made permeable with 500 μL of 95% ethanol (4°C) for 20 min and counted in a γ-counter. The DNA content of each well was subsequently determined after trichloroacetic acid precipitation, by the diphenylamine method (27). Based on the specific activity of the substrates, the efficiency of the γ-counter, and the DNA content of each well, iodide and perrhenate uptake were expressed as picomoles of substrate transported per microgram of DNA.
The time courses of uptake of perrhenate and iodide were determined after incubation of substrate at concentrations of 20 μmol/L for 5, 10, and 30 min in both hNIS-transfected and nontransfected MDCK cells. Additional measurements at 30 min were performed in the presence of perchlorate.
The effect of substrate concentration on uptake was determined by incubating washed cells for 2 min in medium containing 8 concentrations of either perrhenate or iodide, ranging between 0.625 and 80 μmol/L. Uptake reactions were then terminated and substrate uptake was quantitated as indicated above. Data were fitted to the theoretic model (v = Vmax × [anion]/Km + [anion]), where Vmax is maximal velocity and Km is the affinity constant, by nonlinear least squares using the Marquard–Levenberg algorithm to yield Vmax and Km values (7,28).
RESULTS
The biodistributions of iodide, pertechnetate, and perrhenate in live mice were remarkably similar. Activity in blood (Fig. 1) decreased stepwise over time, with little activity remaining at 19 h. Activity in NIS-expressing salivary gland was severalfold greater than in blood, remained elevated over the initial 2 h, and subsequently washed out (Fig. 1). In the stomach, the concentration of activity was even higher than that in salivary gland at 20 min and continued to increase through 2 h, thereafter falling by the 19-h time point. Similar patterns characterized pertechnetate and perrhenate uptake by the thyroid, in which the 2-h concentration was slightly more elevated than the 20-min time point. However, uptake subsequently decreased by 19 h. In contrast, iodide continued to increase through the 19-h time point, presumably as a result of organification (Fig. 1). Coinjection of perchlorate resulted in a relative increase in vascular activity at 20 min, probably because it was not removed by NIS-bearing organs when this potent NIS-inhibitor was administered. Addition of perchlorate sharply decreased uptake of all 3 radiopharmaceuticals by the stomach, salivary glands, and thyroid and resulted in their rapid clearance, paralleling clearance from the blood pool (Fig. 1).
Activity in tissues that do not express NIS (liver, muscle, spleen) was low and rapidly decreased over time (Fig. 2), paralleling blood-pool clearance (Fig. 1). Although some studies have reported small amount of NIS expression in cells in the collecting tubule of the kidney, the pattern of uptake we observed in the kidneys resembled that of tissues without significant NIS expression (Fig. 2) (29). Addition of perchlorate did not greatly change the magnitude of uptake in these tissues, although there was a tendency for the activity to be slightly higher at 20 min in the kidney, probably as a result of the absence of competition by NIS-bearing organs. Uptake by various tissues at 20 min and 2 h was also expressed as a localization ratio of the specific activity in each tissue to that of the blood (Table 1). Uptake ratios for each of the 3 radiopharmaceuticals in thyroid, stomach, and salivary glands were >1 and increased between the 20-min and 2-h time points. Liver, spleen, kidney, and muscle, as well as all organs in the presence of perchlorate, had ratios < 1.
Images in representative mice (Fig. 3) demonstrated the marked amount of gastric uptake noted for all 3 radiopharmaceuticals on the 24- and 60-min images. By 24 h, the stomach was less well defined and, at least in the case of 99mTcO4−, activity appeared to be more distally located within the bowel. For 99mTcO4− and 188ReO4−, a modest amount of concentration of activity was seen in the region of the thyroid gland at 24 and 60 min, but this faded by the 24-h time point. In contrast, 123I− gradually increased between the 24-min, 60-min, and 24-h images. Time–activity curves based on ROIs over the stomach, mediastinum, and thyroid (Fig. 3) demonstrated similar appearances for the 3 radiopharmaceuticals over 60 min. Uptake in the stomach was most intense and increased over the 1 h of initial imaging, reaching 20%–25% of injected activity. The magnitude of thyroid uptake was less, reaching 5%–7% of injected activity. In contrast, mediastinal activity, reflecting blood pool, gradually decreased over the initial 1 h of measurement, constituting approximately 2% of injected activity at the 60-min time point.
To formally assess the transport properties of perrhenate accumulation by NIS, we investigated the time course of accumulation of both iodide and perrhenate in hNIS-transfected MDCK cells (Fig. 4A). Steady-state uptake was approximately 4-fold higher for iodide than for perrhenate at the 30-min time point. No active transport was demonstrated in the nontransfected MDCK cell lines, whereas the addition of perchlorate effectively blocked uptake in the transfected cell line.
To determine the kinetic parameters of perrhenate uptake, initial uptake rates (2-min time points) were measured at different substrate concentrations. Saturation kinetics were observed (Fig. 4B). Based on the Marquard–Levenberg algorithm (28), the apparent Vmax values for perrhenate and iodide were 25.6 ± 1.4 and 106 ± 3.2 pmol/μg, respectively, and the corresponding Km values were 4.06 ± 0.87 and 24.6 ± 1.81 μmol/L.
DISCUSSION
Imaging and ROI analysis have graphically demonstrated the similarity of perrhenate distribution to distribution of pertechnetate and iodide. Because the administered concentrations of these substrates are so much lower than their Km values, they are not believed to interfere with each other, assuming Michaelis–Menten kinetics.
When coadministered, pertechnetate, perrhenate, and iodide had similar uptake and biodistribution in NIS-expressing and non-NIS-expressing tissues, with the exception of the thyroid gland, where iodide continued to be retained through 19 h, as a result of organification. Activity in the NIS-bearing tissues exceeded the blood concentration of activity severalfold. Uptake was highest in the stomach, intermediate in the salivary gland, and lowest in the thyroid. Although this may reflect differential activity of the symporter in the various tissues, stomach activity may be artifactually increased as a result of retention of secreted activity within the lumen. Uptake values in the thyroid may also be artifactually decreased as a result of the unavoidable inclusion of nonthyroidal tissue in the samples, thereby diluting the per-gram uptake values. Perchlorate markedly abolished uptake by NIS-containing tissues while paradoxically increasing concentration in non–NIS-bearing tissues, presumably because of a lack of competitive uptake by the NIS-containing tissues. This phenomenon was also apparent in a previous study of rats, measured at 30 min after injection (22).
Our in vivo murine studies were supplemented with cell culture measurements in which the amount of substrate could be rigorously controlled. In cultured cells that permanently express NIS, perrhenate was transported with an affinity even greater than that of iodide, agreeing with previous measurements performed using other techniques (30). The higher affinities of perrhenate (Km = 4.06 μmol/L) and iodide (Km = 24.6 μmol/L) compared with those previously reported for ClO3− (Km = 277 μmol/L) and NO3− (Km = 739 μmol/L) may relate to their significantly larger ionic radii (1.88 Å for perrhenate, 2.2 Å for iodide, 1.66 Å for ClO3−, and 1.45 Å for NO3−), presumably leading to an improved symporter-binding fit (9,30,31).
In contrast to the present findings, in an earlier study using rat thyroid NIS expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes, Eskandari et al. (9) did not detect perrhenate transport into the oocytes, although they found perrhenate to be a potent blocking agent for NIS, second only to perchlorate. It is possible that the lack of uptake reported on the basis of Eskandari’s electrophysiologic measurements was the result of a 1:1 Na+/perrhenate stoichiometry or differences related to expression in amphibianversus mammalian cells (32). The present results are less prone to artifacts in that we have used a stably transfected MDCK cell line to study uptake. NIS-dependent perrhenate transport in MDCK cells is also corroborated by our whole-animal uptake studies of 188ReO4−, which demonstrated a high degree of uptake in NIS-containing tissues, qualitatively similar to that of 99mTcO4− and 125I−. Our data are qualitatively consistent with those recently reported by Van Sande et al. (33) in FRTL-5 cells and in NIS-transfected COS cells, although quantitatively different because we observed a 3- to 4-fold-higher accumulation of iodide as compared with perrhenate (Figs. 4A and 4B), whereas Van Sande et al. reported a higher relative uptake for perrhenate than iodide.
Because effective therapy depends on retention of radionuclide in the target, a major variable in the use of NIS-targeted therapy is the rate of egress of radionuclide from the tissue (34). Retention of iodide has been studied in tumors transfected with NIS, where short effective half-times of residence have been found (35–40). In an attempt to prolong the retention time of radioiodine in various tumor types, thyroperoxidase has been cotransfected in addition to NIS, with variable results (38,39). An alternative approach may be to optimize the characteristics of the therapeutic radionuclide (40). 188ReO4− is a promising candidate based on its high uptake by NIS-expressing tissues and the energetic β− emissions of 188Re. The degree of uptake and retention may be sufficient for delivery of therapeutic doses of radiation to NIS-expressing tumors, considering the average β− energy of 188Re (which is almost 7-fold higher than that of 131I−) and its considerably shorter physical half-life (17 h vs. 8 d for 131I). In an experimental model of breast carcinoma, we have previously demonstrated that 188ReO4− was able to deliver a dose to the tumor 4.5-fold higher per megabecquerel administered than 131I-NaI (20). In fact, absent organification of perrhenate by the thyroid gland may also be considered an advantage in therapy of nonthyroidal NIS-bearing tissues, in that the thyroid will not serve as a sink for radiopharmaceutical and will sustain less radiation damage. The currently available procedure to decrease uptake by the thyroid gland is the administration of exogenous thyroid hormone, which transiently down-regulates thyroid-NIS and thereby decreases radioiodine uptake.
CONCLUSION
As we enter into the era of NIS-based diagnostics and therapeutics, understanding the biologic behavior of perrhenate in addition to that of iodide and pertechnetate will facilitate modeling and allow a rational choice of radionuclides with the most appropriate physical characteristics for imaging and therapy of NIS-expressing tumors.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge Dr. Judah Weinberger’s assistance in obtaining perrhenate. This work was supported in part by the National Institutes of Health DK-41544 (NC) and CA-95377 (ED).
Footnotes
Received Aug. 14, 2003; revision accepted Nov. 3, 2003.
For correspondence or reprints contact: Lionel S. Zuckier, MD, Department of Radiology, New Jersey Medical School, P.O. Box 1709, Newark, NJ 07101-1709.
E-mail: zuckier{at}umdnj.edu